
In May 2018, the Supreme Court had not yet decided South Dakota v. Wayfair. Online sellers, states and affiliate businesses were watching a dispute that could change who had to collect sales tax on remote sales.
The Court issued its decision on June 21, 2018. The official opinion overturned the physical-presence rule associated with Quill and National Bellas Hess. A seller's lack of an office or other physical presence in a state therefore could no longer be treated as a universal shield from sales tax collection obligations.
For brand leaders, the practical task is to connect current state requirements with accurate sales, operational and partner information. That requires collaboration between tax advisers, finance, ecommerce and the affiliate team.
Why the dispute mattered
The debate involved competing concerns. States and local businesses argued that remote sellers could receive an advantage when they did not collect tax at checkout. Online sellers raised the cost and complexity of complying with different jurisdictions and rules, particularly for smaller businesses.
The relevant historical cases were National Bellas Hess in 1967 and Quill in 1992. South Dakota's 2016 legislation challenged the existing physical-presence standard, leading to the Wayfair litigation.
Sales tax collection and the underlying tax are also different questions. The dispute concerned sellers' collection responsibilities; an uncollected tax at checkout did not necessarily mean a purchaser had no use-tax obligation.
Economic nexus requires a state-specific review
Economic nexus refers to a connection based on economic activity, such as sales into a state, rather than relying solely on a physical location. The relevant test, effective date and registration requirements must be checked for the jurisdiction and period involved.
Do not apply a threshold from an old article across your entire business. As a concrete example, South Dakota's 2023 legislative update removed its remote-seller 200-transaction criterion effective July 1, 2023. The state retained a gross-sales test. The transaction count associated with the original case is consequently not an adequate description of the later rule.
For a review with your tax adviser, assemble:
- Sales by destination, date, product type and selling entity.
- Direct-store and marketplace transactions, clearly distinguished.
- Refunds, exemptions and other adjustments relevant to the applicable calculation.
- Existing registrations and filing histories.
- Physical operations, inventory locations and other relevant business relationships.
- Dates when the business entered a market or changed its operating model.
The tax team can then determine which activity counts under each rule and what obligations follow. A marketing dashboard alone will rarely contain all of that context.
What affiliate managers need to understand
Before Wayfair, some retailers responded to affiliate-related nexus rules by ending relationships with publishers in particular states. Those decisions could disrupt revenue for independent affiliate businesses.
That history should not become an automatic instruction to exclude today's partners by address. An affiliate's independence does not, by itself, settle every state tax question. Equally, removing an affiliate may not resolve obligations arising from other sales or business activity.
Have qualified advisers assess the actual arrangement before making a program change. The affiliate team should be able to describe what the partner does, how it is compensated, where relevant activity occurs and what the contract permits. Avoid substituting a generic label such as 'publisher' for the underlying facts.
Keep compliance decisions connected to the customer experience
Once finance and tax teams establish the requirements, coordinate their implementation with ecommerce operations. Review tax presentation at checkout, order records, refunds and reporting. Test the process before a major promotion so partner traffic is not directed into an unreliable purchase experience.
Clarify the commissionable sales basis in program terms. Partners should understand how taxes, shipping, discounts and refunds are handled in their compensation without needing to infer the calculation from inconsistent reports.
If a legal or operational change affects a partnership, explain the specific change, effective date and next step. Give partners an appropriate contact rather than leaving them to diagnose a sudden loss of access or payment.
Build a review process that can keep up
Maintain a responsible owner for monitoring state requirements and for escalating changes in sales volume, inventory or distribution. The Streamlined Sales Tax state-guidance directory can help locate state information, but the applicable state authority and professional advice should control the tax determination.
Wayfair resolved a major historical question. It did not remove the need to understand the rules applying to a specific business, state and period.
At iAffiliate Management, we help brands coordinate partnership operations with the decisions made by their internal specialists. Talk with our team about affiliate program operations.






