Mar 18, 2013

Affiliate Nexus Tax: A Publisher’s 2013 Perspective

In a guest essay published on March 18, 2013, Andrew Kardon described how affiliate nexus concerns affected his work as a New York publisher. His account showed the business consequences of a tax debate that could seem abstract from outside the industry: lost merchant relationships, uncertainty about future revenue and difficult decisions about where to operate.

Kardon was introduced at the time as the president and co-founder of JoeShopping.com and JoeVote.com, with affiliate experience dating to 1998. The business experiences below are his, and the merchant policies he described belong to that period.

What the affiliate nexus debate meant to a publisher

The debate concerned when an out-of-state seller's connections to a state could create a sales-tax collection obligation. Affiliate relationships were part of that discussion because publishers could refer customers to merchants located elsewhere.

For Kardon, the immediate consequence was commercial. Some merchants were unwilling to accept or retain affiliates located in New York because of their nexus concerns. A publisher could lose access to a program even when the audience and the merchant's products were a strong match.

This was not a separate tax on the affiliate commission described in his essay. The dispute centered on the seller's collection responsibilities and how merchants responded to their understanding of those responsibilities.

Losing relevant merchant relationships

Kardon named Overstock.com and ThinkGeek as examples of merchants he wanted to promote at the time. He considered their products a fit for his coupon and deal audience, but described being unable to join their programs because his business was based in New York.

His response was practical: without a commercial relationship, he could not justify committing the same resources to promoting them. The limitation affected which offers his business could develop and which merchants could benefit from its audience.

That distinction matters. The problem he described was not a lack of customer interest or poor affiliate performance. It was a change in the conditions under which the merchant was willing to work with the publisher.

Why the earlier coupon-site sale became more attractive

Before JoeShopping, Kardon and his business partner operated another coupon site. In his account, the site ranked well for searches involving popular online stores and performed strongly in a number of merchant programs.

He recalled that the first terminations seemed manageable because the business participated in many programs. As more merchants withdrew, the risk became harder to dismiss. Past performance did not protect the relationship when a merchant made a broad location-based decision.

Kardon said that uncertainty was a significant factor when an opportunity arose to sell the coupon site. The prospect of replacing more lost programs represented a substantial amount of work, with no clear assurance about how the situation would develop.

The business was sold to a California company. Kardon's account described that buyer as facing a different affiliate nexus environment at the time of the transaction. That historical comparison does not describe California's current rules, and the essay did not establish an exact transaction date.

The New York or New Jersey office decision

When Kardon and his partner started JoeShopping, they expected to face similar questions again. Living near the New York–New Jersey border gave them an option to consider: opening an office in New Jersey.

The choice involved more than a tax label. New York was the more convenient place for them to operate, and they worried that moving across the border might only provide temporary relief if the rules changed there as well.

They ultimately established their office in New York. The episode illustrates how uncertainty can influence business-location decisions even when the owners would otherwise prefer to stay where they are.

Reopening conversations with merchants

Kardon reported that persistent, direct conversations helped him rejoin a small number of programs that generally excluded New York affiliates. Those conversations involved emails, telephone calls and an explanation of his business.

In his account, some merchants required special terms restricting promotions directed at New York customers through email or social channels. He described accepting those limits in exchange for renewed access to the program.

Those arrangements were specific to the merchants, facts and rules of that period. They should not be copied as a current method of avoiding sales-tax obligations. A restriction that one merchant accepted in 2013 does not establish what another business may do now.

The relationship lesson is narrower and useful: a clearly explained business model can support a more informed conversation than an unanswered application. The legal conclusion still requires the appropriate expertise.

The advocacy concern behind the essay

Kardon wanted a more consistent environment in which publishers could plan their businesses. He pointed to the Performance Marketing Association's work on behalf of the industry and argued that differing state approaches placed an unfair burden on affiliates.

That position was part of his historical perspective. His central concern was the effect of uncertainty on small businesses: a publisher could invest in traffic, content and merchant relationships, then lose part of that opportunity because of a policy change outside its control.

What changed after the 2013 account

On June 21, 2018, the US Supreme Court's South Dakota v. Wayfair decision overruled the physical-presence rule associated with Quill and Bellas Hess. Physical presence was no longer a necessary condition for a state to impose sales-tax collection responsibilities.

New York's current remote-seller guidance explains that businesses without physical presence can have registration, collection and remittance obligations when the state's requirements apply. This is one reason an affiliate's location alone is not a complete assessment of a merchant's obligations.

Current decisions need to consider the applicable state rules, the seller's activities and the relevant facts with a qualified tax adviser. Removing affiliates or copying a historical contract provision should not be treated as a substitute for that review.

The program-management lesson

We retain this publisher perspective because it shows how commercial decisions reach the people running partner businesses. When a program changes eligibility or terms, clear communication and an accurate explanation matter.

Our related article on the habits that frustrate affiliate partners develops Kardon's broader message about preparation, responsiveness and respect for the publisher's work.